Chris Dreyer:
Remember the early days of LSAs? Clicks were cheap, competition was non-existent, and the firms bold enough to jump in, cleaned up? In marketing, you win by capitalizing on new attention before the crowd shows up, and costs explode. Today, we're taking the inside live ChatGPT Ad campaigns running across more than 100 law firms. This is Personal Injury Mastermind. I'm Chris Dreyer, founder, and CEO of Rankings.io, the elite performance marketing agency for personal injury law firms. Breaking down the data are Rankings.io's director of paid ads, Jessica Ford, key account executive Megan Grothman, and partnerships consultant, Danny Define. Today we cover real cost per case data from live PI campaigns, navigating contextual bidding with zero keyword targeting, and structuring a discipline test before ad cost search. Let's get into it.
Megan Grothman:
We are in this kind of early mover growth phase. So, we saw this with LSAs. I think that we really have an opportunity here to show up where people are turning for legal advice, right, or wrong. People are going to ChatGPT, they're figuring out maybe if they have a case, or where they should turn, and you have the opportunity to have your firm surfaced among those results. Laddering back to LSAs, and what a gold mine those were whenever we started. I think we're kind of in that phase now with ChatGPT Ads, but I know that's changing really quickly. So, I would encourage those who haven't acted yet to seriously consider adding ChatGPT to your repertoire in 2027. And I think a lot of people have seen strong results. We'll cover how these ads work, what it costs to test, and what results we've tracked so far.
These are still in data, so we'll talk about what that means specifically for your firms. And we just hit 104 law firms, so we have quite the test group. We've been able to learn, and we're seeing these changes that ChatGPT is rolling out in real time. So, I think that offers a lot of insights that a single marketing manager, or somebody working inside of a firm just doesn't have. And Jess, I'll invite you to take it away.
Jessica Ford:
Awesome. Okay, so bit of a mixed bag for early results from ChatGPT as we would expect for anything like this. However, we are seeing cost per cases of ChatGPT Ads for multiple firms hover around $300. This is for PI. Now, I will say we are also seeing some cost per cases even lower than that for branded searches. Now, what we think is happening is users are looking up the law firm that they're interested in contacting to learn more about them. When those ads show up, it's almost like a branded campaign. For those, we're actually seeing very, very low, like $30 cost per case signups for people who are already interested. But really quick, this is what the ChatGPT Ads look like in the wild. You can see a lot of the conversations that we're seeing, and again, we can only do this with live testing, is people just asking if they even have a case. And so you can actually start to see one to two of these ads show up at the bottom very clearly marked as ads.
Megan Grothman:
Yeah. And Jess, is everyone seeing ads, or are there specific people that these ads would be served to?
Jessica Ford:
These ads are only served to people on the free plan right now, and the Go plan with ChatGPT Ads. All right, so diving in a little bit more about how ChatGPT Ads work. ChatGPT Ads is going to show your ads on relevant conversations, or related conversations, and it's a model-driven ranking system right now. Again, it's in beta. There's not a lot of clarity on what that means right now. However, there are things like bidding strategies. So, if you're familiar with Google Ads, we can do maximize clicks, or maximize conversions. And of course, just like with Google Ads, it is an auction-based pay-per-click format.
Megan Grothman:
Cool. And I've heard about a couple of new features that are rolling out. A couple of things are sponsored agents, and integrations with HubSpot, and Shopify. Are those available for firms yet, or is that something that is just being tested?
Jessica Ford:
There's a lot of e-commerce features right now that are available that are not rolling out for law firms, or for other sensitive verticals right now.
Megan Grothman:
Got it.
Jessica Ford:
So, again, this isn't beta. If those of you who remember the early days of LSAs, we're seeing very similar behavior. First, fair warning, cost per click. It is very volatile right now. We are seeing it jump $10.00, $12.00 back down to $9.00, up to $34 even for the same firm, or market even within the same month. Overall, they are trending upwards though. I will warn you about that. Current bids right now average for PI nationwide, what we're seeing is about $15.00. We tend to see them hover around $9.00, $12.00 still, especially for early adopters in emerging markets up to about $40 on the very high end.
Megan Grothman:
Does the cost per click vary based on market, or is it how well optimized the account is? What sort of trends are you seeing?
Jessica Ford:
It seems to be based on market, but because it's a beta ad platform, it's kind of hard for us to benchmark.
Megan Grothman:
I was going to mention, just as I'm having these conversations with firms, I'm recommending between 2000, and 3000 for a test budget per month. Is that still accurate?
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, that's still accurate. You can actually get away with a little lower if you're in a smaller market, like a smaller town. You might want to hover closer to a 5K test if you're in a really big expensive market.
Megan Grothman:
Got it. And is that the same recommendation regardless of practice area, like personal injury?
Jessica Ford:
Correct.
Megan Grothman:
Okay.
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, correct. Same for all.
Megan Grothman:
Cool.
Jessica Ford:
Okay. So, one thing to know about a beta ad platform like ChatGPT Ads is reporting is not super robust just yet. And so what you see here is about what you get for reporting. It really doesn't dive into any more details than this. So, this is an example recently just from the last 30 days from one of our accounts. You can see in the metric trends at the bottom, average cost per click, you can see it kind of going up, and down. That kind of volatility is not typical of something more established like Google PPC, but this is exactly what we're seeing in a pretty expensive market right now for one of our clients. And then you can see on the graph at the top, spend, impressions, click, cost per click. We can pull click-through rate, but that's about it. There is not much more detail for reporting available right now.
Danny Define:
Jess, this is from Mike here in the chats. He mentioned running ads on branded queries similar to a branded search campaign. Mike wants to know, can you run a similar campaign but on a competitor's brand names? Example, law firm A wants their ad to show on chat searches when someone is researching their competitor. Law firm B, is that possible? Have you tested this? If so, what were the results, and what was the overall impact on CPCs, and cost per conversion?
Jessica Ford:
So, right now, no, we can't quite do that. And that has to do with the nature of the platform right now. So, we can't do keyword targeting like we can on Google Ads, or Bing ads right now. We use what's called contextual targeting, and then the ad platform itself actually pulls information from your landing page, and from your ad itself, and tries to match it to a relevant conversation. So, there's no way, even if you tried a contextual hint listing competitors, there's no way to know if it fired for those competitors, or not. There is no query reporting available whatsoever on ChatGPT Ads. So, can your ads kind of conquest another firm? Maybe. It would be really hard to prove.
Danny Define:
Thank you for that. And before we move on to the next slide, to piggyback on that, this is from Chris coming in. Can you target questions, or queries for specific types of accidents? For example, a car versus truck, or slip, and fall, construction accident?
Jessica Ford:
Yes. So, yes you can. So, the way we like to structure ads, and I'm going to kind of get in the weeds here a little bit, we now understand that what ChatGPT Ads likes to see is ad groups broken up by specific sub-practice area. So, you can have a campaign say MVA, and under that campaign you'll have an ad group for car accidents, ad group for pedestrian accident, ad group for truck accidents, and each of those ad groups will have a series of ideally five to 10 ads going to the same landing page with just testing different messaging. We find that that kind of robust targeting with the contextual targeting, which is now allowed for law firms as of about four weeks ago, we can get as close as we can to targeting, but it's more like a signal than an actual keyword target. Okay, so again, this is probably a good kind of rehash again of what we're seeing.
Really limited reporting. The way we're tying, for example, information is a lot of manual work. So, we know, for example, that one of our clients had a $30 cost per case come from a ChatGPT Ad that we know was branded because we tied that user to a referral. So, you're going to have to do a lot of manual work on your end to see how well ChatGPT Ads is working since the reporting is so limited. I will warn you, the account itself, the platform is very glitchy. So, if you are new to ChatGPT Ads, you try to sign up, maybe it freezes, maybe you get an error, just know that is normal. Just refresh your page, or open a new browser, and that usually solves the issue. So, again, good, and the bad, it is affordable, although getting more expensive as we speak. It's a great time to get in.
We're seeing really good results for a lot of our law firm partners here, but changes can happen without warning, so you need to be very flexible. Do not set it, and forget it. This is not the time to turn on cruise control.
Megan Grothman:
Yeah. And Jessica, with that, are there specific firms that immediately come to mind that would be a great fit for ChatGPT Ads versus are there specific firms that maybe should wait? What are you seeing?
Jessica Ford:
I recommend for law firms, you want to have a CRM, and a way to track where leads come from. That is probably the most important thing because otherwise you're really not going to know if it's working, or not. And I would recommend law firms have a test budget. So, this isn't something where I would just turn it on willy-nilly, have a plan, understand that it's an experiment, and a test, and I would be willing to put in, I recommend two months, two month test to see how it works for you.
Megan Grothman:
Perfect. And I actually have a question I thought of, and I think we've talked about this. We're talking about ChatGPT Ads. Don't send me hate mail because I'm bringing up other channels, but are there other AI ad platforms, Claude, or anything else, that are offering ads, and would you recommend them?
Jessica Ford:
So, not yet, but we are watching very, very closely. I have to bring up kind of the elephant in the room that is AI mode in Google Gemini. Right now, Google Gemini is very, very shy of letting law firms advertise on any of its AI overviews, or AI mode. I don't expect that to last, but right now we are having a very hard time proving that Google Ads is showing law firms in AI mode. So, that is available in theory, but it's not. It's a little shy policy-wise.
Danny Define:
Jess, Chris had a follow-up question here. Can you target by language preference?
Jessica Ford:
You can, yes. You can target by language and location.
Danny Define:
Okay. And then we have one here from Brian before we move on. So, one, the budget question. For those of us working with a more modest budget, is there a low end to the budget at which point I won't learn much from a test?
Jessica Ford:
We have run several tests for law firms for under a thousand dollars. So, I would say 700, 750 would probably be the absolute lowest I would recommend for a law firm. Run it for 30 days, and see how it goes. That would be probably the most modest budget I recommend.
Danny Define:
I guess everybody's morning coffee is kicking in right now because now we're getting flooded with the question.
Jessica Ford:
No, this is great.
Danny Define:
I was waiting For that to happen. It's such a hot topic the last couple of years. Now the floodgates are opening up with these questions. We'll jump to another slide, Jess, and we'll circle back to these questions here in a bit if that works for your cadence.
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, absolutely.
Megan Grothman:
Well, and we do want to offer additional value here. So, if you're hearing all of this, all of these insights, and deciding, "Hey, I actually want to set up ChatGPT Ads, let's run the test." You can comment me, and we will send you our checklist for getting started. This is specifically what we send firms when we're setting up accounts on their behalf. And fair warning, checklist looks a little intimidating, but it's the honest setup, and exactly what you would need to get started. Obviously, we are also here to help, so the information will come straight from me, my email, megangrothman@rankings.io. Watch for it, and we'll make sure you get whatever support that you need.
Jessica Ford:
And as an extra bit of incentive, just so you all know, as of right now, ChatGPT Ads is still offering a $500 credit for new accounts. I believe you have to spend 500, and then they'll grant you that $500 credit if you're new.
Megan Grothman:
Awesome. Love to see all the interests, too. Thanks guys.
Jessica Ford:
Oh, my gosh, exciting.
Danny Define:
Yeah, hold on, my fingers are about to fall off. I'm scrolling all the way up here to find these questions. They got about 87 mes to scroll up from. Oh, what's up, Lee? We touched on this a little bit earlier, but Lee Rudin, one of our favorites here. Lee just asked, "What do you recommend as the minimum budget for, and what duration to test ChatGPT Ads?" Is there a minimum budget, or testing period there?
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, I would recommend minimum 750 for 30 days.
Danny Define:
And this one comes from Christina. "Do you see higher conversion rates/successful cases than typical lead sources?"
Jessica Ford:
Ooh, good question. I would say our biggest struggle is volume, and scaling. And so ChatGPT Ads, it's not like Google Ads where you can just say, "Here's $100,000, let's go." Actually, that is one of our biggest challenges right now is scaling the volume of cases coming from ChatGPT. We are just naturally limited by the platform right now. I expect that to change on the high end. We do have clients paying up to 30K a month on ChatGPT.
Danny Define:
Wow. And this one comes from Mike. So, how accurate are the contextual targeting capabilities? Example, say a PI firm wants to generate car accident injury leads, keyword injury, and someone who's been in a fender bender, and did not sustain any injuries would not be part of the TA. Is it possible to, for example, show ads on, quote, "car accident injury type queries", but not showing ads on quote-unquote "car accident queries" that do not contain, or indicate a sustained injury?
Jessica Ford:
So, you can give the contextual hints. This is kind of like how they're structured right now, and this is actually coming directly from ChatGPT themselves. You want to have your service, the use case, the relevant terminology, and the qualifier, but it is a hint. So, the short answer is no, we don't have that much control over ChatGPT Ads right now, but you can be pretty specific with what you're looking for.
Danny Define:
And Angel looks like has a comment here. "I noticed there is no call button in ChatGPT Ads." Angel says that they're running one for a PI firm in Florida. It's only optimized for clicks. "I started a ChatGPT Ads for immigration lawyer for Boston, optimized for conversion. However, it's not getting any traffic. What is your advice for tracking ChatGPT Ads?"
Jessica Ford:
So, really good question. I'll give you a couple standard best practices, and then a trick we're testing, and have seen results from. So, standard tracking, you want to set UTN tracking parameters with that pixel that ChatGPT has available, and then pull in those leads as a conversion action. Make sure you apply it manually to the campaign. ChatGPT Ads doesn't just automatically apply it like Google, and Meta do, you have to apply it specifically to the campaign. If you have CallRail, or something similar like CallMetrics, you can do a direct integration with ChatGPT Ads. So, if you have a website pool, CallRail can actually track that traffic from, and phone calls from ChatGPT Ads. Here's the trick right now, even though there's not a click to call button on ChatGPT, it is not disallowing phone numbers in ad copy. I don't know how long that will last, but right now it is letting us do it. So, what we've been doing for some of our clients is setting an external number just for ChatGPT itself on CallRail, and then applying that number in ad copy, and we are getting leads from that.
Danny Define:
Wonderful. Jess, I think you're the most popular guest we've had on these webinars this year. You're getting a ton of questions here coming in.
Jessica Ford:
No, no, this is great. I love it.
Danny Define:
People are really fired up about the ChatGPT Ads. This one's from Miles. So, what do click-through rates look like with ChatGPT Ads? I know we've touched on that briefly, but...
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, they're low. ChatGPT Ad click-through rates are really low, because of course the ads themselves show up at the bottom of a conversation, and they're very obviously ads, and so a lot of people will just avoid them. Right now, standard click-through rate we tend to see is between 5%, and 1%. I rarely see ads go above 1%.
Danny Define:
Wow. And you have some fan mail here from Austin. Jessica is great. She is great.
Jessica Ford:
Oh, hi Austin.
Danny Define:
Nice. Virtual round of applause for Jess here. And of course, Megan, this has been fantastic. Okay. From Eric, does cost vary based on practice area?
Jessica Ford:
Really good question. Honestly, no, not that we've seen. I've seen family law have about the similar cost per click as PI. I don't know how long that will last.
Megan Grothman:
One thing that I don't know that we touched on, I've heard that the costs are rising pretty quickly. So, Jessica, can you speak to that? And maybe if you're planning a test, might want to do that sooner than later.
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, I recommend sooner rather than later if you want to take advantage of cost, and lower competition. The longer you wait, probably the more robust the account beta platform will be. But on the flip side, you're going to run into high costs. Regardless, whether you start now, or wait, expect a lot of volatility. Again, a lot of the numbers I'm giving you guys right now can change in one week. Even the best practices can change. Even after the podcast with Chris, just a few weeks ago, it has changed so much. So, just be aware of change, and just again, watch it really closely. The number one mistake you can make right now is set it, and forget it.
Danny Define:
Okay. We still have questions flowing in here. I don't know if we want to try to wrap this up or... Jess, what do you think? Do you have time for one more question, or should we...
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, I got time for one more. Really good question on the location targeting. So, really quick to know about that. You can do postal zip code, or you can do metro area. We've been leaning towards metro areas just for a slightly wider radius, or you can go statewide if you're comfortable with that. Keep in mind we're entering intake. You need to be able to close the leads. We're not just chasing visibility.
Danny Define:
Okay. Well, yeah, let's wrap there. This is fantastic stuff. I know there's still some questions that we need to get to, but we'll save that here for the follow-up because we are sharing this webinar with everyone, so keep an eye out for that. And then as far as just staying in the loop with all things, whether it's ChatGPT Ads, or really anything groundbreaking here in the legal space, we have a couple QR codes here. Please subscribe to the PIM newsletter. Drops every Monday, new edition of that. And then also the PIM podcast with Chris Dreyer. We'll leave those QR codes up there for a few seconds. If you want to scan, subscribe, again, get up to date on all of the latest, and greatest things happening in the legal space. Hear from the experts like Jess, and Megan. Jess, Megan, both of you so much. Thank you for hopping on today, and for everybody tuning in.
Jessica Ford:
Yeah, thanks for having us.
Megan Grothman:
Thanks, Dan, and-
Chris Dreyer:
When a brand new ad platform launches in beta, it's always glitchy. Reporting is bare bones, and click costs swing wildly. You can't just put it on cruise control, and walk away, but when you have the discipline to track every lead through your CRM, picking up personal injury cases for $300 is the kind of edge that completely transforms your acquisition math. Don't sit on the sidelines where your competitors drive up the cost per case, get in early while the window of opportunity is wide open. That's it for today's episode. Personal Injury Mastermind is powered by Rankings.io, a legal marketing agency for elite law firms specializing in personal injury law. If you want more auto, and truck accident cases, choosing you instead of the competition, book a complimentary growth audit at rankings.io.